Suing a forum software company in a Small Claims Court

jjrogers21

New Member
Jurisdiction
California
The company is from the USA, California and I will be filing a case against them in a small claims court (LA area). I got the software more than two years ago (May 2014) and after I moved the software to a new hosting plan I was not able to fix the issue with images not showing on the site (old already uploaded images and I am not able to upload new ones too). I checked their website and manual, made sure that are the hosting requirements are met and after I was not able to fix the problem by myself, I have contacted their support through the forum on their site (this is free and comes with the purchase of the script). I had one person from there who was trying to fix it for five weeks, and after he directly admitted that he was not able to fix it, I contacted the supervisor from there. The supervisor was working on this for over two months and was not able to fix it too. During the fixing process these people were asking me stupid and unnecessary questions (like "What is the first letter in the alphabet" lets say, it was obvious, they did not have to ask me and wait three or more days with a reply) and I was also getting wrong info from them more than once (the supervisor said, the problem is this and it does not work because of this, but I tested what he was talking about and it took me less than a minute to do it and this was wrong info, all this worked as it should). I was also told to move the program to PHP 5.xx or 7.0.11 and after I worked on setting this up for more than five hours I was told after three or more days that the 7.0.11 PHP is not good for this (I've picked the 7.0.11 one as this is a newer version, so I thought it would be better out of the two) and that he needs the 5.x.x for that. So this is basically blaming Linux, Red Hat, PHP, MySQL / MariaDB aspects of this (the software that runs the Internet all over the World) for the fact that the website does not work and this is not true. I have 5 other scripts (all different products) on this hosting plan and everything has been working as it should from the day one. So basically they are not able to fix it, they give me wrong info, waste my time, and this was to the level of being disrespectful to the person who got the software (me), and so on.

On the top of the software fee I ordered an expensive graphic design which was added to the site. This graphic design will not be good for any other scripts that I could be using so I would like to get a refund for this too. The total amount will be around $1050.00 and I want to recover the cost of the law suit as well (telephone fees, process server, and all costs related to this, not a lot). The company is from the USA and I am located in Europe and I will be filing the case over the Internet (along with the SC105 asking the court for the Court Call - I was told this over the phone by the related Small Claims Court representative).

I signed an agreement and I went over it now and it has something like this in there (the only part that needs to be taken into consideration I think):

"8. Limitation of liability.

Except for the exclusive remedy offered by vbulletin solutions in section 7 above and any remedies that cannot be excluded or limited under law, vbulletin solutions, its affiliates, resellers, and certificate authorities will not be liable to you for any loss, damages, claims, or costs whatsoever including any consequential, indirect, or incidental damages, any lost profits or lost savings, any damages resulting from business interruption, personal injury or failure to meet any duty of care, or claims by a third party, even if vbulletin solutions has been advised of the possibility of such losses, damages, claims, or costs. In any event, vbulletin solutions' aggregate liability and that of its affiliates, resellers and certificate authorities under or in connectioin with this agreement will be limited to the amount paid for the software. This limitation will apply even in the event of a fundamental or material breach by vbulletin solutions of this agreement. Vbulletin solutions is acting on behalf of its affiliates, and resellers for the purpose of disclaiming, excluding and limiting obligations, warranties, and liability, but in no other respects and for no other purpose.

The foregoing limitations and exclusions apply to the extent permitted by applicable law in your jurisdiction. This limitation of liability may not be valid in some jurisdictions. You may have rights that cannot be waived under consumer protection and other laws. See section 19 for e.U.-specific statements. Vbulletin solutions does not seek to limit your warranty or remedies to any extent not permitted by law. This section 8 will survive the termination of this agreement."

I am not sure whether this just means that they wont pay for the graphic design part in any circumstances and there is nothing that I can do to get these money back.

In general I've been preparing for this for over two days, and I've seen some videos about the small claims process on the Internet. At this point I would like to find the laws that are applicable to this and laws that I could use against this company. The company has a legal department and lawyers working for them so they may be coming to the court to go over the case. So this is me, a person from Europe not even there - Small Claims Court in the LA area - and the lawyers from the forum company that I will sue. I know that it would be good to know the law, so I can base this case on this, and I could possibly get some other info too, if I could (from this forum, on what to do, how to approach it and so on).
 
If you aren't prepared to fly to Los Angeles to appear in court (and you don't get your travel costs back) you will have to petition the court to allow you to appear by telephone. If the judge says no, then your lawsuit is over.

As for how much you can sue for, you can sue for any amount you want but, according to that contract, you are unlikely to win anything but a refund and even that is unlikely since you apparently used the software successfully for two years and then it was incompatible with your new hosting plan.

You might only end up with a partial refund if you even get that.

Or nothing, depending on what that "exclusive remedy" in Section 7 was.

You haven't posted that and it also has to be taken into consideration.
 
Thanks for the answer. I was talking to the Small Claims Court clerk over the phone (the one that I need to use for that case) and I was told that it is ok not to be there, but I need to fill out the SC105 form (asking the court for a court call, the form can be downloaded from the Net, and what I am planning to do is in the LA area, California). I know that this may not be easy and I am trying to research as much as I can and prepare so there is a chance that I will not loose the money for the lawsuit. On the other hand the vBulletin has bad reputation and it is possibly that people sue them there like once per week, or even more, I am not sure. I am not the first person suing, I am sure. There are entire website made by people who tell people how bad the program has become / is. This does not matter though. As far as I was watching the videos on the Net, it is the law that is important and the judge will be making the decision based on that. It could be good to imagine that the judge will be against me right from the start and I need to find a way to prove the somebody else in charge over the judge that he / she is not correct based on the California law. This could be the best way of preparing the case. I may be contacting the government institutions there (like Department of Justice, Better Business Bureau and get some advice from there too). I know that this may not be easy, they have full time lawyers working for the company and they have the agreement that I signed. The agreement does not seem to be as bad as I thought it could be, and at the same time they probably cant ask you to sign a total waiver of their responsibility for the product or something like that. I am not a lawyer and not a lawyer from the United States so this is not an easy thing to research. I wont be hiring a lawyer because the lawsuit amount is low (a little more over $1000), but at the same time I would not like to loose these $1000. They messed it up and the money should be mine, as far as the justice goes or should go, so why would I not win this case can be questionable too. I mean, in real life, on the street, I got something from them, it is not good, they cant fix it, I lost money, so I should get these money from them. There is all these law, but what would be the purpose of it if it just makes it harder for people to get the "justice" that is on their side.
 
What you fail to grasp is that should you prevail, you don't receive a check.

You receive a judgment.
You must then perfect that judgment.
Once that formality is overcome, you then must endeavor to collect on the judgment.

Statistics reveal that fewer than 10% of all small claims judgment holders ever collect ANYTHING on their judgment.

That ANYTHING might be $5 or $10, not the $3,000, or whatever the plaintiff sought.

Small claims courts are simply another government device to soothe an angry public, making money for the government, rarely collecting money for the populace.
 
The Better Business Bureau is not a government agency. It is an ineffectual-at-policing-its-members private entity.
 
I know this forum isn't for something like my reply but I thought I would share my 1 or 2 cents.

Rule 1: When dealing with PHP, never think newer is better. While PHP 7 is in a stable build, it is still not very "stable".

Also, different distros of an OS behave differently than the others. It is nearly impossible to test all features of a language on all variants of an OS. Just because you use for example Fedora that doesn't mean that your script(s) may work the same as Ubuntu. PHP for Win is different for PHP on *nix.

Also your issues could be HTTP errors. Apache and NGINX so if you check your relevant errors logs something may show up.

Another one of the issues may be file permissions. You may want to check your directory and file permissions on your HDD and those can be a nuisance, some scripts/files don't require open permissions but some do and some don't require a full open permission (0777,0755,0644, etc).

Another option is to roll back. Most hosting companies have an easy way to switch PHP versions. 5.6 is a great one especially if you may be using VB 5 (don't quote me, I don't own a license).

I will say as a programmer that the chances of you winning a lawsuit are pretty slim because if they can show that they run their software on the specs they call out for then they did nothing wrong and at best, since they have licensed software, they can refund you he money (unlikely, you've had a license for 2 years) and cancel your license.
 
Back
Top