Chances are your bank will give you back the $75, but be sure to answer their letter (they usually send a letter after you speak with them, to confirm the dispute). I seriously doubt that the web host can hurt your credit even if they wanted to. They probably don't intend to do more than try to...
Proof of delivery to show Paypal would help. Call their customer service and find out what you need to do. And in future, beware of using Paypal, as they do have a reputation for making things difficult for sellers.
There was an ice storm in my area in late February and part of an oak tree on an adjacent lot cracked off, fell on and crushed part of my fence. I'd like to know who is responsible for replacing the fence.
I photographed the icy limbs on top of the fence the day it happened, and called the...