Unfair Ejection from Required Course

Status
Not open for further replies.

StudentConcern

New Member
I am a Spanish Education Major. I was taking my third pre-service course (similar to student teaching but for less time during the day). I was ejected from the course 7 days from completion without warning.

The claims against me were that: 1) I wore biker shorts while teaching one day, 2) I exposed my mid-drift and generally dressed unprofessionally, 3) I was unprofessional in my administration communication and, 4) I tried to start an after-school program incorrectly.

These claims are obviously not true (like #1) or poorly founded (such as #4 - I consulted teachers, wrote written proposals and spoke with adminstrators). Regardless, these matter little. The point I make is that protocol on my University's behalf, was not followed. I was never given any warning (verbal, written or otherwise) by my teacher, supervisor, or the program director and neither was my advisor/head of the department. Furthermore, there was nothing written, to my knowledge, stating that ejection from a school meant automatic failure of the course.

Additionally, I was told this in a meeting with my supervisor and the program director. I was told of the situation, which made me visibly upset (crying) as I've worked very hard to be a teacher, and was then told I had to sign a contract stating I would not contact anyone in the district I pre-service taught in ever again. Not even to apologize. I feel this dabbles in the contract under duress rights, as it was not presented in a manner that seemed like an option and I wasn't in a right state of mind to begin with. Furthermore, my supervisor shushed me several times during the explanation of the ejection when I was trying to explain that I didn't do X or Y - such as the bike shorts which were an obvious falsity. She also made comments to my personality which she had little to no basis upon which to make them and no need really.

After this occured, I late-dropped the course to avoid an F on my 3.73 GPA credentials. I spoke with my advisor who agreed that the situation was unfair. We tried to contact various people to come up with an acceptable alternative for the course (seeing as I only missed a few days), such as visiting other schools for those days or doing an analysis project on the problems stated from my pre-service experience, etc. Nothing was accepted. Later, I was told that the assistant-dean of the college of education had allowed for a graduation of ED without certification (meaning I'd have the degree but I wouldn't be able to teach with it). Later, while trying to get my degree audits and concurrent major forms filled out, I was informed I was not allowed to do this by an academic advisor. I am just now finding a solid answer to the problem, which is that I am allowed to graduate with a degree in Spanish by taking the last few required courses but my other majors (Spanish Ed and International Studies and ESL Ed - which require I have the Spanish ed major - will not be possible without retaking the pre-service course and then taking the student teaching semester after that).

This is a larger problem for me as I am set to move to Texas in late August which creates a problem teaching (as I could have otherwise obtained a certificate in PA through emergency teaching laws) and in finishing on time to move, as well as blow to my finances.

Really, I am over the whole thing and will simply graduate this May with a Spanish degree and 2 minors, but I want someone to apologize or even acknowledge that the university was in the wrong and unprofessional in the way they handled that matter and to make sure this kind of thing doesn't go unnoticed in the future.

Do I have a case/would it be worth it?
 
Something seems to be missing here. It's my experience that it is very difficult to be removed from a student teaching or preservice assignment. I have seen student teachers moved to other classrooms when they're having problems, but never removed completely, and some of those student teachers made serious errors in judgment!

If you had to sign a contract stating that you would never contact anyone within that entire district ever again, then it was probably requested by the district. That's pretty extreme.

I'm sorry that I don't sound more empathetic, but I've never heard of these extremes. I believe there must be more to the story.
 
I understand the bizarre nature of the event. That is why I'm on this site. If I had done something legitimately wrong, I wouldn't be considering legal action in the first place.

Assuming nothing is missing (cause it isn't to my knowledge) what would your thoughts be?
 
Well, I'm not a lawyer, I'm a teacher, so I can't really tell you whether or not you have a case.

I sympathize with you. It does seem unfair to go so far, then be prevented from finishing.

I do have a few thoughts though. For some reason, the district must have requested that you agree not to contact anyone there. I don't know if the contract you signed is enforceable, but the alternative for the district might be a restraining order against you. I think you're better off with the contract. Perhaps your university was working in your best interests when they had you sign it.

Did you dress unprofessionally? Were your interactions with the administration unprofessional? What are the problems that you would have written about in an analysis project? Are these the things for which you would like to apologize? I suspect that the your director's comments about your personality may have something to do with your interactions with administrators. Is that possible?

Did your cooperating teacher and supervising teacher write any evaluations during your preservice? Most programs require one or two evaluations prior to the final evaluation. If so, did they note any concerns?

If there had been no concerns expressed to you throughout your preservice, then I'm surprised you were ejected without some sort of serious error on your part. However, since you could not complete your clinical hours, you would have failed the course, and I doubt the university is required to find replacement hours for you. In other words, even if you had been allowed to complete those hours, you would have received a failing grade for the preservice. I guess I'm saying that your university may have had no choice in this matter. If the district ejected you, your university couldn't do much about that.

I don't know if you can take any legal action against the university. I don't think so, but I really don't know. Hopefully someone with more legal knowledge will respond.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top