Someone I know was charged with a crime. He said he did not do it but they charged him because he is one of 2 or three people that could have had access to commit the crime. He cant afford an attorney but he wanted to try to find out what evidence the D.A. is planning to use against him. Is there some sort of Discovery that he can do himself? Can he go to the courthouse and file a form to make them turn over their evidence to him? Thanks!
-
Welcome to our legal community! Click here or the create new topic button to ask a question and receive answers and comments from our friendly and helpful legal community.
Articles that answer frequent legal questions are in our Law Guide. Important legal news is reported in The Law JournalYou can find a lawyer near you in the Lawyer Directory. If you know that you need to hire an attorney, you can submit a case review from a lawyer.
Can someone request evidence against them prior to hearing?
- Thread Starter Ruger20
- Start date
- Status
CdwJava
Moderator
Usually, discovery is obtained by his assigned counsel - either retained or appointed by the court. He will probably have to wait until that time.
- Carl
- Carl
Has he gone to court yet for arraignment? They will read the charges against him at that time and that is when he enters a plea and also asks for court appointed lawyer if he is unable financially to get one on his own. He must follow through and fill out documents for a court appointed lawyer at that time, usually with the court clerk. He may need some sort of proof like pay-stubbs, or tax return to prove he is unable to pay or if he is unemployed a statement from the city's workforce commission or whatever it is called in your state. So he may want to get that ready and take with him, so if they ask for it he will already have it. FYI: Court appointed isn't neccessarily free...could be sliding scale or some sort of set fee. Once he has a lawyer, then the lawyer will ask for discovery and discuss your friend's options. When you say access are you saying like keys to enter a place? Is there a time frame the crime was committed where an alibi would be helpful? Just curious : )
Has he gone to court yet for arraignment?
He received a ticket and was told they would send him something or call him with a court date.
When you say access are you saying like keys to enter a place?
It was a code that needed to be entered
Is there a time frame the crime was committed where an alibi would be helpful?
I think it was during his shift at the establishment that he managed.
Another question, if he can prove his innocence, does he have a wrongful termination and/or defamation of character case?
He received a ticket and was told they would send him something or call him with a court date.
When you say access are you saying like keys to enter a place?
It was a code that needed to be entered
Is there a time frame the crime was committed where an alibi would be helpful?
I think it was during his shift at the establishment that he managed.
Another question, if he can prove his innocence, does he have a wrongful termination and/or defamation of character case?
CdwJava
Moderator
Sounds like how they do juvenile court citations in California.Ruger20 said:
What's he being charged with? Burglary? Embezzlement? Theft?
Not good for him.
If the termination was with cause and reasonable, he would likely have no case. He would likely have to show that his employer acted recklessly and intentionally - and knowingly - in falsely terminating him.
- Carl
CdwJava
Moderator
How does he know he has been charged with a crime? Has he been arrested? Has he been arraigned? If not, then it could just be that the accusation has been made but the matter has not yet been presented in court.
- Carl
- Carl
Well, the police came to talk to him at his work and said, "You can come down to the station voluntarily, or we can arrest you." Then I guess he went down there and talked with them and they fingerprinted him and such, then wrote him a ticket type document and said he would receive something in the mail stating when his court date was. It seems like they are trying to pull something here.
CdwJava
Moderator
It seems they have not yet filed the matter with the DA, so he may have time to breathe. I would recommend your friend consult with an attorney ASAP as it sounds like they intend to file soon.
- Carl
- Carl
seniorjudge
New Member
It actually is my friend, this is the internet, if it were me, I would say it was me. Its not like someone is watching me type and I have to hide :yes:
- Status
Share this page
