Withholding Security Deposit in Uninhabitable Apt.

Status
Not open for further replies.

RasTheExhorter

New Member
My jurisdiction is: Los Angeles, CA

I'll try to be clear and concise with this... my former landlord failed to remedy (after 60 days of a written notice) multiple repair issues and insect infestation issues that per California law violate the Implied Warranty of Habitability and Health Code. My fiancee and I discovered that California Civil Code offers a tenant a way out of a lease - Code 1942 - for just such violations.

We moved out at the end of this past October, turned in the keys at the requested final walk-thru with a letter stating that we were leaving per Civil Code 1942 - Uninhabitable Conditions. The landlord said that there was no damage to the unit, in fact claimed that it was cleaner than when we moved in and that we would get the entire security deposit back, because he had found a new tenant.

After the allotted 21 Days, the Landlord only gave us 1/2 the security deposit back claiming that we gave him a 30 Day Notice in the middle of October - which we never formally did, just told him at the beginning of October that we needed to move because of health reasons, which was true and can be documented by a doctor -- when we moved out and said that we were responsible for 1/2 month's rent for November. His reasoning was he lost the new tenant (as if that's my problem). It seems to me that if the Landlord was willing to discharge our liability for any rent, then all rent should be discharged, not just 1/2 a month.

I'm planning on taking him to Small Claims court to recover the balance of the Security Deposit, plus 2x per California Civil Code 1950.5(1) and other damages associated with being out of pocket close to $2000

I wanted to know if anyone has any advice for how I should present my case to the Small Claims Judge?
 
Since your claim for breaking the lease is the failure of your landlord to address repair and insect infestation issues, you'll have to prove in court that these things took place.

I'm assuming you kept your documentation to him. Do you have pictures of the insect infestation?

Gail
 
I have pictures of all the other issues (gaps in the door frame to the outside, crumbling linoleum floor in the kitchen, Gas Company service tech advice re: a potentially explosive gas heater, spider bite marks on my arm - all things that fall under California Civil Code 1942), except for the actual insect infestation... I wasn't able to get photographs of the flies and spiders. I have a few shots of the cockroaches. All of the things I was allergic to and I have doctor documentation for that.

And I kept a copy of every single written communication with the landlord.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top