Thanks everyone, I appreciate all of the advice. I think we have almost reached an agreement between us and hopefully this will be over soon. Thanks again!
Here are all of the conversations where things got fishy. They are copied and pasted, with only the names changed.
----
Nine months after I shipped my male to him:
FLORIDA: I actually started my season late this year so I only have 4 eggs from him and Girl #3 right now. Girl #2 isn't back up...
What exactly is a meeting of the minds? We talked over the phone to discuss the terms of the contract, and then both signed the contract (note: we never met face to face and neither signature is notarized). Here is the contract:
I live in Fort Wayne, Indiana and I entered into a breeding loan contract with a person in Coral Springs, Florida. I am now looking at taking him to small claims court because he breached the contract and will not agree to what I think is the fair way to resolve the issue.
The contract states...