- Jurisdiction
- New Mexico
I hired a handy man to install laminate flooring in my rental property. Upon completion of the project I reviewed his work and found it to be substandard. I requested that he corrected his work before I would paid his bill. He offered to correct the work if I paid him more. I offered to hire another contractor to correct his work and should a balance exist I would send him a check. He instructed me to move forward with my other contractor that he didn't have time to redo my project. Once the work was completed there was a credit of $240. On the check I wrote balance for the flooring and he cashed it. I recently put my property on the market and found out that he placed a mechanics Lien against it. I have copies of my emails and the check showing when it was cashed. Does the fact that he cashed my check close our contract?
I hired a handy guy to install flooring in my rental property. The work did not meet my expectations and I informed the installer that I would not pay his bill unless he corrected his work. He responded that he felt his work was satisfactory but that he would correct it if I agreed to pay him more money. I refused and told him that if he prefers I can hire another installer and once the bill is satisfied I'll send him the balance if any exists. He agreed to this arrangement. Once the work was completed there was $240 left over. I send the original installer a check for this amount and noted balance due on flooring. He then cashed it. I have all my emails and a copy of the check. I recently put my property on the market and was informed that he had placed a lien against it. I noticed that the lien was filed prior to him requesting that I move forward with my other installer. The title company has requested that he sign a release and he has refused. Does the fact that he cashed the check indicate that our contract was closed? What are my rights?
I hired a handy guy to install flooring in my rental property. The work did not meet my expectations and I informed the installer that I would not pay his bill unless he corrected his work. He responded that he felt his work was satisfactory but that he would correct it if I agreed to pay him more money. I refused and told him that if he prefers I can hire another installer and once the bill is satisfied I'll send him the balance if any exists. He agreed to this arrangement. Once the work was completed there was $240 left over. I send the original installer a check for this amount and noted balance due on flooring. He then cashed it. I have all my emails and a copy of the check. I recently put my property on the market and was informed that he had placed a lien against it. I noticed that the lien was filed prior to him requesting that I move forward with my other installer. The title company has requested that he sign a release and he has refused. Does the fact that he cashed the check indicate that our contract was closed? What are my rights?
Last edited by a moderator:
