I purchased 12 autographed sports cards (same player) from a seller on eBay and immediately submitted them for authentication through a reputable (and eBay approved) autograph authenticator. Needless to say, they came back as fake. The total cost for the cards $511.50, $360 for the authentication service, plus shipping, insurance, and other related costs. Through eBay I'm sure I can recover the $511.50 and I e-mailed the seller who recommended I call him to work it out. The seller is located in New York, about 50 miles from me, and his previous listings include similar type items (same era, multiple of the same player) that may suggest he is very well aware of the situation. Aside from recovering the initial purchase price, how best can I attempt to recover my losses and/or press criminal charges against him? Thanks in advance.