It certainly seems clear to me, but from what I've seen in discussion threads ebay/PayPal seems to have a habit of issuing refunds without requiring Shop America Airlines/Sekaimon to return the item or somehow prove that it is still in the US. Could ebay be interpreting "compensated by a third...
How is Sekaimon/ Shop Airlines eligible for buyer protection?
(sorry, can't post links)
Eligibility for eBay Buyer Protection:
Even if the damage was caused during shipping to Shop America Airlines, the "purchases compensated by a third party" clause (third party is the actual buyer) should...