I still don't know what to do next. If I pay back the net that I received, I don't believe the company will reduce my earnings by the gross amount. So that will not resolve the issue. Do I have any other recourse?
Thank you. I appreciate you checking further. I don't believe that paying the net amount will produce correct results because the company insists that I have to pay the gross amount.
My company issued an extra paycheck to me in error after I retired (not my fault), and subsequently sent me a letter requesting that I return the gross amount of the overpayment. I think it is reasonable for me to return the net amount that I received, but not all of the deductions.
The gross...