Thank you very much for the insight. I should have mentioned that we did attempt to contact the website directly. It was no surprise that they never responded via email, and had no phone number listed on their site.
Using WhoIs, I was able to find that they registered their domain through...
Stoughton, WI
We received notification from Geddy Images that we were using an unauthorized image on our website, and after removing it from our site they are seeking $900.00 in compensation.
At no point did we intend to defraud Geddy Images or use this image to make money, in fact up to...